Leave a Message
Thank you for your message. I will be in touch with you shortly.
Explore My Properties
Sunlit contemporary Pinecrest kitchen with a white quartz island, pale oak cabinetry and views of a lush private tropical garden.

Asking Prices Versus Sale Prices in Pinecrest's $2 Million-Plus Market

November 19, 2026

In 2020, a lot on Old Cutler Road in Pinecrest sold for $1.5 million. Four years later a new 11,600-square-foot house stood on it. That house, 13291 Old Cutler Road, went on the market in February at $19.5 million and sold for $17.5 million, as The Real Deal reported in July. The deed was recorded on July 7, according to the Gables Courier. An agent with BHHS EWM Realty represented the buyer.

It was the biggest Pinecrest sale of the third quarter, and it still sold $2 million below its asking price. That gap shows up across Pinecrest's upper tier this fall. The homes for sale above $2 million and the homes that actually sold above $2 million are two different sets of houses. If you are comparing Pinecrest with Coral Gables or Palmetto Bay from a listings screen, you are mostly looking at the first set.

The shelf and the sold list don't line up

From July 1 through September 30, 2026, Pinecrest recorded 47 single-family sales at $2 million or more, worth $203.7 million together. That figure comes from a deed-based quarterly count covered by the Gables Courier. No condo in the village sold at that level during the quarter. The same report took a snapshot of listings on October 14, 2026, and found 20 Pinecrest homes on the market at $2 million or more.

$2M-plus single-family Q3 2026 sales, July 1 to Sept. 30 Listings on Oct. 14, 2026
Count 47 20
Median price $3.375 million $5.63 million asking
Weighted price per square foot $931 $1,126 asking
Total value $203.7 million about $121.3 million asking

The median asking price on October 14 was about two-thirds higher than the median sale price for the third quarter. The asking price per square foot was about 21% higher than what buyers paid per square foot over the summer. The listings and the sales are different groups of homes. In the third quarter, 11 of the 47 sales reached $5 million or more, so about three in four closed between $2 million and $5 million. On October 14, at least half of the 20 listings were asking more than $5.6 million.

The October listings had been on the market for an average of 14 days. That makes the fall shelf mostly new arrivals. Many of the homes in the $2 million to $5 million range never sit on the market long enough to drag that average down. The expensive homes stay listed longer, so they make up more of what you see when you browse at any given moment.

That has a practical effect when you compare towns. Miami-Dade's single-family luxury threshold, defined as the top 5% of sales, was $4.2 million for the first three quarters of 2026, according to MIAMI REALTORS. The typical $2 million-plus Pinecrest sale this summer, at $3.375 million, closed under that county line. The typical Pinecrest listing in October was asking well above it.

The top of the sold list is new construction, and it closed under ask

At Pinecrest's top end, the most expensive homes are recently built, and even those sold for less than their asking prices this year.

Take 6290 Chapman Field Drive. It is a newly completed house of nearly 12,000 square feet on just over an acre, not on the water, north of Deering Bay and west of Gables by the Sea. The Real Deal reported that a company led by builder Fouad Kraishan sold it for $13.5 million after asking $16.3 million. Ignacio Permuy of Coral Gables-based Permuy Architecture designed it. The sale came in about 17% below the asking price, which works out to roughly $1,130 a square foot.

The Old Cutler Road house closed about 10% under its February asking price, at roughly $1,500 a square foot. Both sales are far above the $931 per square foot the third-quarter group averaged, and that difference is the premium for a finished new house. Both also show that buyers at that level negotiated the asking price down by a meaningful amount, even in a year when million-dollar sales across South Florida rose 20% through September, according to MIAMI REALTORS chief economist Gay Cororaton, as the Gables Courier reported. Cash made up 59% of those South Florida sales, so mortgage rates in the mid-7% range had little to do with the discounts.

Even at $17.5 million, Old Cutler Road did not set a village record. That record is still the $19.5 million sale of 6555 SW 102nd Street, a 2022 house that sold in 2025. The Real Deal was still calling that sale the record in August 2026. In other words, $19.5 million is a price one Pinecrest home has actually sold for. In February, the Old Cutler Road house was asking the same amount, and the buyer paid $2 million less.

What the asking price pays for, and what it doesn't

A new Pinecrest spec home is priced to recover the cost of the land, the construction, and the years between buying the lot and selling the house. Old Cutler Road shows that timeline at its smoothest: the lot was bought in 2020, the house was built four years later, it was listed in February, and the sale was recorded in July.

Not every project moves that smoothly. Another one-acre Pinecrest site sold in 2021 for $1.6 million to become a spec home, and the house there has stood partially built since 2022 after construction financing fell through. The two lots were bought for about the same price a year apart. Their outcomes so far are very different.

That difference is why a finished, inspected house sells at a premium per square foot. Buyers at $10 million and up are paying not to carry the building risk themselves. The sales above show they are willing to pay a lot for that, but not the full asking price. A new build's asking price usually reflects what the seller hopes the house is worth. The recorded sales price shows what a buyer agreed to pay once the house was finished and had been on the market for a while.

The pipeline is still producing new homes. A Pinecrest house completed in 2023 at 6060 SW 118th Street went under contract in late August with a $9.6 million asking price. Each new spec listing like that raises the median on the listings screen before it has any effect on the median of what actually sells.

Reading a Pinecrest listing this fall

For a buyer comparing Pinecrest with nearby towns, the $3.375 million third-quarter median and the $931 weighted price per square foot are the better guides to where the $2 million-plus market actually trades. They cover sales from July through September 2026, so they reflect summer pricing and include older homes along with new ones. A house built in 2011, 10101 SW 60th Court, sold for $13.4 million this spring. An older house with the right land and location can sell near the newest construction.

Three numbers help when you look at any individual listing. First, its asking price per square foot compared with the $931 summer average. Second, whether it is new construction, where this year's top sales closed 10% to 17% under their asking prices. Third, how long it has been on the market compared with the 14-day average from mid-October. A new spec home asking $1,500 a square foot that has sat for two months is in a different position than a renovated 1990s house asking $900 that arrived last week. The listings screen shows both of them the same way.

For sellers, the same numbers point the other way. An owner of an older Pinecrest home in the $2 million to $5 million range is competing in the tier where most of this summer's sales happened, not against the spec homes at the top of the screen. Pricing against the recorded sales instead of against the asking prices nearby is how a home in that tier avoids becoming one of the listings that sits. Our Pinecrest neighborhood page and home valuation tool are good places to start. For estate owners weighing timing, our guide to planning the sale of a Pinecrest estate home covers preparation.

Whether you are looking at a new build on Chapman Field Drive or an older house off Old Cutler, Pam Mayers and The Mayers Group can compare it with what Pinecrest homes like it actually sold for, so you know how far its asking price sits from the recorded sales. Let's Connect and schedule a consultation.

Follow Us On Instagram